How we work
How our honest ratings work
Every remedy on Remedies by Culture carries one of four ratings. They tell you how much is really known about a traditional use, so you can enjoy the tradition without being sold a promise.
Why we rate every remedy
Many remedies have been passed down for generations. Some have since been tested in good studies, some have only history behind them, and a few popular ones have been tested and come up short. A single rating on each remedy makes that difference easy to see.
Our ratings describe the evidence for one specific traditional use, such as honey for a cough. They are not a verdict on the ingredient as a whole, and they say nothing about whether a remedy is right for you.
Studied
A remedy is rated Studied when the European Medicines Agency recognises it as "well-established use", which requires published scientific literature showing recognised efficacy and acceptable safety, or when a Cochrane or other systematic review of clinical trials finds a positive effect.
Example: honey for a cough. A Cochrane review found that honey probably eases cough symptoms in children more than nothing at all or a placebo, and NICE in the UK lists honey as a self-care option for people over 1 year old. The review also notes the limits: most children were followed for just one night. Studied means the evidence points the right way, not that it is a guarantee. Honey is never suitable for babies under 1.
Traditional
A remedy is rated Traditional when the EMA has published a traditional-use monograph for it. For traditional use, the EMA does not require clinical trials. It requires sufficient safety data, plausible efficacy, and at least 30 years of medicinal use, including at least 15 years in the EU.
Example: thyme for a productive (chesty) cough. The EMA's conclusions on thyme medicines for this use are based on traditional use. It is a respected, long-standing use with official safety guidance, but it has not been proven in the way a Studied remedy has.
Cultural practice
A remedy is rated Cultural practice when its use is documented in a culture but it has not been properly studied for that purpose, and no EMA monograph covers it. We still describe how and why people use it, because the tradition is real and worth knowing.
Example: té de canela, the cinnamon tea many Mexican and Latin American families make when someone has a cold. Cinnamon is widely studied for other reasons, but NCCIH notes the results are hard to interpret, and we know of no good research on cinnamon tea for colds. So we say exactly that: cultural practice, not studied.
Myth-busted
A remedy is rated Myth-busted when good-quality reviews have tested a popular claim and it does not hold up.
Example: vitamin C megadoses to prevent colds. A Cochrane review of 29 trial comparisons involving more than 11,000 people found that taking vitamin C regularly did not reduce how often people in the general population caught colds. It found small reductions in how long colds lasted with regular use, which we report too. The idea that big doses stop you catching colds is the part that is busted.
Why traditional does not mean proven
A long history tells us people found a remedy comforting and that, used in the usual way, serious harm was not obvious. It does not show that the remedy works better than rest and time, and it can miss rarer side effects or interactions with modern medicines.
That is why a Traditional or Cultural practice rating always comes with safety flags, and why we write "traditionally used for" rather than claiming results.
When the evidence conflicts
Studies sometimes disagree. When they do, we give more weight to systematic reviews than to single studies, and more weight to large, well-run trials than to small ones. If the picture is still mixed, we choose the more cautious rating and explain the disagreement on the page.
Ratings can change. When new reviews or monographs are published, we update the rating and the last-checked date.
Sources
- Herbal medicinal products (European Medicines Agency)
- Honey for acute cough in children (Cochrane review, 2018) (PubMed)
- Cough (acute): antimicrobial prescribing (NG120) (NICE)
- Thymi herba (thyme) (European Medicines Agency)
- Cinnamon: Usefulness and Safety (NCCIH)
- Vitamin C for preventing and treating the common cold (Cochrane review, 2013) (PubMed)
By the Remedies by Culture editorial team · Last checked 1 October 2026 · Not medical advice, and not medically reviewed. How we work
