Myth check · Updated 28 October 2026
Natural remedy myths, checked against the evidence
15 of the 148 home remedies in our library are myths. Studies or health authorities find they don't do what people believe, or there's no good evidence for the claim, and a few can cause harm. Each one links to its full write-up and sources.
Which home remedies are myths?
These are the 15 we rate Myth-busted, with what the evidence says and any harm to know about.
| The belief | Where you hear it | What the evidence says |
|---|---|---|
| Taking big doses of vitamin C to ward off colds | United States | A Cochrane review found regular vitamin C doesn't prevent colds in the general population and only slightly shortens them; starting it once a cold begins showed no consistent benefit. People under heavy physical stress, like marathon runners, were an exception. |
| Dairy makes more mucus | United Kingdom | In a study of adults given a cold virus, milk intake wasn't linked to more mucus, and a later review reached the same conclusion. Milk can briefly feel thick in the mouth and throat, which may explain the belief. |
| Rubbing lemon juice on skin to fade dark spots | India | Lemon juice doesn't reliably fade dark spots, and it can make them worse. Citrus contains furocoumarins, which make skin react to sunlight, causing redness, blisters and dark patches that can take months to fade. The acid can also sting and irritate skin. |
| Dabbing toothpaste on a pimple overnight | United States | Dermatologists advise against it. Toothpaste has no proven effect on acne and can irritate the skin, causing redness, dryness and peeling. Products made for acne are gentler and backed by evidence. |
| Sea moss is a superfood for immunity | Trinidad and Tobago | There's no good human evidence that sea moss prevents colds, improves immunity or clears skin, and the '92 minerals' slogan is marketing, not a tested nutritional fact. Seaweed can contain a lot of iodine and some heavy metals, and reviews warn that too much iodine can upset the thyroid. |
| Mustard plasters clear a cough | Ukraine | There's no good evidence that mustard plasters ease a cough or shorten a cold. Mustard is a strong skin irritant, and case reports describe burn-like blistering after mustard was left on the skin. |
| A rakia rub brings down a fever | Bulgaria | MedlinePlus advises against alcohol rubs for fever: they cool the skin but can cause shivering, which raises core body temperature. A case report describes poisoning after a rub with rubbing alcohol (isopropanol); that's a different alcohol from rakia, but it shows alcohol on the skin can be absorbed. |
| A salt steam bowl clears a cold | Italy | There's no good evidence that steam bowls help a cold: a Cochrane review found no clear benefit from breathing heated, humidified air, and those trials didn't test salt or bicarbonate bowls. A consultant at an NHS burns centre in Wales warns that steam bowls cause serious burns in children and adults every year. The NHS suggests steam from a hot shower if you want to try steam for a blocked nose. |
| You should eat more with a cold and fast with a fever | United Kingdom | There's no good evidence that eating more helps a cold or that fasting helps a fever. NHS self-care advice for both is the same: rest and drink plenty of fluids. Adults can take paracetamol or ibuprofen if needed, following the label; ask a pharmacist first if you're pregnant, have a health condition or take other medicines, and use children's versions at the right dose for children. |
| A shot of kirsch helps you digest fondue | Switzerland | In a randomised trial in 20 healthy Swiss adults, published in the BMJ in 2010, fondue left the stomach more slowly when eaten with white wine and a shot of kirsch than with black tea and water. Digestive symptoms were the same either way. It was a small study in healthy people, but it shows alcohol doesn't speed digestion of a fondue. |
| Flat cola settles a stomach bug | United Kingdom | Cola is high in sugar and very low in salt, which is the opposite balance to oral rehydration solution, and losing the bubbles doesn't change that. The NHS advises against fizzy drinks and fruit juice during diarrhoea because they can make it worse, and NICE guidance for young children says to discourage them too. Water, squash in small sips, or rehydration solution are the recommended drinks. |
| A yearly laxative purge cleans you out | Jamaica | There's no evidence that a regular purge removes 'toxins' or does any good. Castor oil and senna are strong stimulant laxatives meant only for short-term constipation; they can cause cramps, sickness, diarrhoea and dehydration, and the Institute of Jamaica notes a wash out can dehydrate. Castor oil can also trigger contractions of the womb. |
| A hot toddy helps a cold | United Kingdom | There's no good evidence that the whisky helps a cold. Any comfort comes from the warm drink, the honey (which may ease a cough a little) and the lemon, which the NHS suggests without alcohol. Alcohol makes you pee more, it fragments sleep so you tend to wake earlier (NIAAA), and it adds to the drowsiness of sedating cold and allergy medicines (NIAAA). |
| Raw onion in your socks draws out a cold or flu | United States | There's no scientific evidence that a cut raw onion absorbs germs or 'toxins' (National Onion Association), and a doctor at OSF HealthCare describes the onion-in-socks reports as purely anecdotal: the cold would probably have got better anyway. It shouldn't replace proper rest, fluids and checking for warning signs. NCCIH notes that no complementary approach has been shown to help the flu. |
| Jamaican black castor oil regrows hair and edges | Jamaica | There's no good evidence that castor oil, black or clear, makes hair grow. A 2022 systematic review found no strong evidence for hair growth and only weaker evidence for shinier hair. Castor oil is a thick, heavy oil; rare reactions include allergic contact dermatitis and sudden matting of long hair. For thinning edges, the AAD's advice is to take the tension off the hairline and see a dermatologist early, because traction hair loss can become permanent. |
How do we decide a remedy is a myth?
A remedy is rated Myth-busted when studies or a health authority (a Cochrane review, the NHS, NIH or MedlinePlus) find it doesn't do what people believe, or find no good evidence for a widely repeated claim that comes with real downsides. A quiet family tradition nobody has tested is rated Cultural practice instead, because no evidence is not the same as evidence against. Read how our evidence ratings work and our editorial and evidence policy.
Which home remedies do have evidence?
10 remedies in the library are rated Studied: studies or an EMA monograph found a benefit for some uses of the main ingredient, but results vary and home preparations often weren’t tested. Each page says exactly what was studied:
- Hot honey and lemon drink (United Kingdom, cough)
- Thai hot ginger drink (Thailand, nausea)
- Ginger and brown sugar tea (China, period cramps)
- Aloe vera gel for sun-exposed skin (Mexico, skin)
- Warm honey and lime drink (Jamaica, colds)
- Peppermint oil on the temples (Germany, headaches)
- Green kiwifruit (New Zealand, constipation)
- Agen prunes (France, constipation)
- Psyllium husk drink (Bangladesh, constipation)
- Mānuka honey in warm lemon water (New Zealand, sore throat)
Keep exploring
- How the world fights a cold →
- How the world calms a cough →
- How the world gets glowing skin →
- How the world gets through flu season →
- How the world settles an upset stomach →
- How the world soothes a sore throat →
- Find a remedy you can make from what's in your kitchen →
- When to see a doctor instead of a home remedy →
- Browse the whole remedy library →
The Remedy Atlas · digital book
How the world heals, honestly rated
127 remedies from 64 cultures, in one beautiful book. Each has its recipe, an honest evidence rating and clear safety flags.



